A Storm on the Horizon: Tesla's Battery Woes in Europe and Asia
Tesla has long basked in the glow of a stellar reputation, a significant portion of which has been built upon its robust battery supply chain. The company's strategic approach of diversifying its battery suppliers has, for the most part, yielded impressive results. In particular, the LFP (lithium iron phosphate) batteries from CATL, lauded for their exceptional durability, have been a cornerstone of this success. However, a disquieting trend has begun to emerge in Europe and Asia, casting a shadow over another crucial battery type powering Tesla's popular Model 3 and Model Y vehicles: the LG Chem-manufactured NCM811 (nickel-cobalt-manganese 8:1:1 ratio) battery packs.
Shocking Revelations from EV Clinic
The unsettling data comes from EV Clinic, a highly respected independent workshop and research center based in Croatia that specializes in diagnosing electric vehicle batteries. Their rigorous testing has uncovered a stark disparity between American-made Panasonic NCA (nickel-cobalt-aluminum) batteries and the Chinese-sourced LG NCM811 packs. The findings paint a concerning picture for owners of Teslas equipped with these particular LG batteries.
A Dramatic Decline in Lifespan and Performance
In practical terms, Panasonic battery packs have demonstrated a remarkable resilience, often enduring approximately 400,000 kilometers (about 250,000 miles) before exhibiting significant failures, and importantly, they remain amenable to repair. The LG NCM811 batteries, on the other hand, appear to be reaching a critical state much sooner, often around the 240,000-kilometer (approximately 150,000-mile) mark. The most alarming aspect isn't isolated component failures; it's the pervasive, uniform degradation across all modules within the battery pack. Experts at EV Clinic have observed an alarmingly high internal resistance in these LG units. To put this into perspective, a 'tired' Panasonic cell might register an internal resistance of around 28 milliohms (mΩ). Astonishingly, new LG cells are already starting from this same 28 mΩ baseline. During disassembly, specialists frequently discover over 15 cells within a 46-cell module exhibiting resistance exceeding 100 mΩ, while the remaining cells surpass 50 mΩ. This widespread aging makes the replacement of a single section impractical, as the other modules are almost guaranteed to follow suit in their decline.
The Financial Toll of a Flawed Battery
The complexity and frequency of these battery issues have created a significant financial burden for EV Clinic. The company admits that its attempts to salvage and restore these problematic batteries result in a monthly loss of over €20,000 in labor costs. Consequently, they have implemented a separate fee solely for assessing the feasibility of any repair. Their candid advice to affected owners is stark: either seek out a pre-owned Panasonic battery pack or petition Tesla for a complete replacement unit.
A Wake-Up Call for Tesla
This report serves as a serious wake-up call for Tesla, especially considering that a substantial volume of these LG NCM811 battery cells were supplied to the European market. While the company's long-standing strategy of leveraging multiple suppliers has generally been a triumph, the stark contrast between the performance of Panasonic NCA and LG NCM811 batteries underscores a critical point: variations in battery chemistry can swiftly transform from a minor technical detail into a very real and costly headache for both the manufacturer and, more importantly, the end-user.
Comments (0)
There are no comments for now