The Persistent GOTY Snub: Xbox Exclusives' 15-Year Drought at The Game Awards
As the nominations for The Game Awards 2025 begin to roll out, a familiar pattern has emerged, casting a shadow over Xbox's flagship titles. For the fifteenth consecutive year, not a single Xbox exclusive title has secured a coveted spot among the Game of the Year (GOTY) contenders. This striking absence, first highlighted by user Nick_Marseil, paints a stark picture of the console's perceived standing in the eyes of awards bodies.
A Shifting Landscape: Trends in GOTY Nominations
The list of nominees for the upcoming awards, announced on the evening of November 17th, features a compelling lineup of anticipated titles. Among them are Clair Obscur: Expedition 33, which has already set historical records, alongside Death Stranding 2, Donkey Kong Bananza, Hades 2, Silksong, and Kingdom Come: Deliverance 2. However, the absence of any dedicated Xbox releases in this premier category is a recurring theme. Examining a graph compiled by Nick_Marseil, which spans from 2013 to 2025, reveals a dramatic skew in favor of competing platforms. Over the past 15 years, PlayStation has amassed an impressive 15 GOTY nominations, while Nintendo has garnered 12. Xbox, in contrast, stands at a disheartening zero.
While there was a momentary confusion in 2021 with the inclusion of Psychonauts 2, it's important to note that despite being published by Xbox Game Studios, the game was not an exclusive and launched simultaneously on PS4, thus not fulfilling the exclusive criteria for a direct comparison. During this same period, PlayStation has celebrated four GOTY wins, and Nintendo secured one victory in 2017 with the universally acclaimed The Legend of Zelda: Breath of the Wild.
Beyond the Top Tier: Xbox's Presence in Other Categories
It's not to say that Xbox is entirely overlooked by The Game Awards. The platform's titles have certainly made their mark in other categories. The action-adventure game South of Midnight is vying for an award in the "Innovation in Accessibility" category, a testament to its forward-thinking design. Furthermore, veteran actor Troy Baker has received a personal nomination for his portrayal of the lead character in Indiana Jones. Yet, the central discussion remains focused on the elite Game of the Year category, where Xbox exclusives continue to be conspicuously absent.
A Look Back: The Last Time Xbox Competed for the Crown
The Gamer delved into the era of the Spike Video Game Awards to pinpoint the last time Xbox exclusives were in contention for the ultimate prize. Back in 2010, two Xbox-related titles were nominated: Halo: Reach, which remains an Xbox exclusive to this day, and Mass Effect 2, a game that later found its way to PS3. Both were celebrated as monumental achievements in gaming, but the coveted GOTY award that year went to Red Dead Redemption, a title that is soon to receive a remaster and potentially expand its reach to mobile platforms.
The Road Ahead: Hope and Uncertainty for Xbox in 2026
The outlook for 2026 offers a glimmer of optimism for Xbox. Anticipated releases such as Halo: Campaign Evolved, a new installment in the Fable series, Gears of War: E-Day, and Forza Horizon 6 are on the horizon. However, the very definition of "exclusive" is becoming increasingly fluid. If these highly anticipated titles, with the exception of Forza, are released on platforms like the PlayStation 5, it could dilute their perceived exclusivity and, consequently, diminish their chances of securing GOTY nominations. Adding another layer of complexity is the looming release of Grand Theft Auto 6, a title that promises to ignite fierce competition and potentially overshadow all other contenders, further challenging Xbox's aspirations for a GOTY nod.
Comments (0)
There are no comments for now